92 So we grabbed seven different brands to try. 41 And in the No. ), ( If you’re looking to add more toppings to your frozen pizza, add some of the best frozen meatballs you can find in stores. And when it came to the pepperoni, we were thoroughly impressed. Taste of Home is America's #1 cooking magazine. ), ( 119 1 spot was its irresistible crust. ), ( 97 ), ( ), ( Overall, Screamin' Siclian's Supremus Maxiumus Supreme Pizza offers a tasty and flavorful combination of toppings on a decently solid crust. ), ( Popeyes Selling "NOLA Strong Meal" to Help Support... Jack in the Box Brings Back $4.99 BBQ Bacon Cheese... Sonic Debuts New Red Bull Summer Edition Watermelo... Smoothie King Introduces New Immune Builder Veggie... Blaze Pizza Now Offering Do-It-Yourself Pizza Kits. Crispy, cheesy and packed with pepperoni, you can’t go wrong. “I’d be the spokesperson for this pizza.”, At the top of our list: Whole Foods 365 Everyday Value pizza. ), ( ), ( 1137 94 Einstein Expands Family Meal Selection with New Br... Frosty Cookie Sundae Returns to Wendy's for a Limi... Review: Jack in the Box - Classic Popcorn Chicken. ), Nutritional Info - Screamin' Sicilian Mother of Meat Loaded Pan Pizza, IHOP Introduces New Classic Breakfast Sandwich. When it came to toppings, the cheese, sauce and pepperoni all got good marks for taste, but we felt there wasn’t enough of them to balance out the thicker crust. They didn’t taste fresh and our testers all agreed that these additions took away from the overall flavor. 42 999 As for those pretty tomatoes and basil? Well, our testers definitely noticed the bold tomato sauce laced with a light Italian seasoning blend. ), ( ), ( ), ( 120 124 64 32 Sonic Introduces New Sweet 'n Tangy Bacon Cheesebu... Denny's Launches New Shareable Family Packs. 99 Classic, budget and choice brands mixed in the middle? There was no correlation between taste and price or brand recognition. It’s very good. ), ( ), ( This is a taste test/review of the Screamin’ Sicilian I’m Thin & Crispy Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza. ), ( Review: Little Caesars - Pepperoni Cheeser Cheeser... Ikea Reveals At-Home Recipe for Their Signature Me... My/Mo Launches Single-Serve Mochi Ice Cream Balls, Orange Cream Shake Returns to Arby's for Summer 2020, Taco Bell Pours New Wild Strawberry Candy Freeze, Smashburger Releases New Take & Make Family Meal Kits. ), ( There was more than one cut of pepperoni, sliced and chunks of it, amply amounts of cheese, real cheese. 21 Our testers were shocked when this store-brand pie was unveiled. She pours this love of all things sweet (and sometimes savory) into Bakeable, Taste of Home's baking club. 115 Coming in right in the middle was Screamin’ Sicilian’s pepperoni-packed pizza. New Little John Combo Available at Participating J... Get $5 Off Panera Takeout Order of $15 or More Thr... Dunkin' Extends Free Donut Fridays for DD Perks Me... Red Robin Offers $1.99 Kids' Meals with Purchase o... Baskin-Robbins Scoops New Cotton Candy Crackle Ice... KFC's New $30 Fill Up is Meant to Cover Two Meals. 105 96 Second place goes to DiGiorno Original. ), ( ), ( ), ( ), ( 46 Overall, Screamin' Sicilian's Mother of Meat Loaded Pan Pizza was disappointing in both crust and meats. ), ( Oh, and the flavor is excellent, doesn't really have that frozen pizza taste. 58 Check which dill pickles and salsa brands were our favorites.). Chees... Free "Thank You Meals" for Healthcare Workers and ... Popeyes Brings Back Blueberry Lemon Cream Cheese Pie. 1183 Score: 5.3/10. ), ( The sauce was blended with oregano, garlic and basil. 84 Immediately the crew of taste-testers made note of the thick, chewy crust. 109 1320 ), ( 17 The pepperoni on the bottom is an unnecessary gimmick that just made for messier eating without contributing much in the way of flavor. ), ( 89 ), ( Would the usual suspects–Tombstone, Red Baron and DiGiorno–prevail, or would choice options like California Pizza Kitchen or new-comer Screamin’ Sicilian be worth the premium price?